Have you ever wondered what it would be like if all the Austen characters were friends and lived in the same town. Hmm, have I asked this before? Oh yeah…
That was a good book, unfortunately this isn’t a review of the next novel in that series but of the TV show:
Yes, all the Austen characters live in the same city, the city of…hmm they never say where this takes place. They all have an American accent except for Emma who is British, sometimes.
I’ve noticed in other episodes it just seems to fade away. She must not be faking it because no one else has one so why would they make her have one? But I cant explain why that happens with her. Anyways…
So it says that it is the Austen characters, but only seems to have Mr. Darcy, Elizabeth Bennet, Elinor Dashwood, Marianne Dashwood, Emma Woodhouse, Mr. Knightley, and Colonel Brandon. Yes there is no one from Northanger Abbey, Mansfield Park, or Persuasion.
I mean really? I wish someone would do “all” the characters and actually have “all” the characters.
So the story takes place in modern times. We start of with Elinor Dashwood (Kristen Marie Jensen) who is an IRS and is complaining to her friends Lizzie Bennet (Elise Groves), real estate agent, and Emma Woodhouse (Shona Kay), divorce attorney. Oops, and friend Grant Knightley (supposed to be GEORGE why change to Grant? I mean George is a common name), played by Brad Johnson, and works with Emma? I’m not quite clear.
HOld on…okay Elinor as a tax accountant, okay I can buy that as she is well organized and great with finances.
Lizzie as a real estate agent, I have a hard time seeing. I could see her more as a writer or Park Ranger or manager at something.
BUT Emma as a divorce attorney?
That’s just crazy. First of all she hates reading-no way. Second, I don not believe someone who tries to match people up all the time could spend days working with separating couples. That makes no sense to me.
So Elinor is bummed her sister will be moving in as she is flighty, boy-crazy, and has no clue what she is doing. As soon as she moves in she starts shaking things up by redecorating and changing things. Elinor gets angry and flips out on her messing up her apartment.
Now I get that Elinor doesn’t want her sister to take over her space, but seriously? You know she isn’t staying for a few nights, but planning to LIVE with you. Unless you specifically drew up a roommate agreement or told her she only gets her room and a shelf in the fridge you are seriously overreacting.
They try to make it seem like Marianne is just doing what she wants-but Elinor is seriously being a control freak.
Calm down. They eventually patch things up and compromise.
Now the clothes that Marianne wears are really weird. 2015 was only four years ago, I remember what was popular and people where wearing and it was not that. Who picked your wardrobe? It is more 2005 than 2015.
Lizzie Bennet has the client William Darcy (Gavin Bentley) who is such a major jerk I am actually hoping they do not end up together.
Yes, a retelling made me actually wish that.
I think the world is going to explode or I’m going to die…too late
Good-bye, cruel world.
Sorry, this post will not be brought to you by the undead.
So Darcy in this is a total pain-complete and utter jerk. I really don’t see how they will redeem him.
Also Lizzie’s parents are planing on divorcing and she doesn’t want them to as she doesn’t want her mother to try to live with her.
Both of her parents are going to Emma, who Lizzie gets to join her in her plan to reunite her parents. Emma plans a dinner date and before you can say The Parent Trap all is solved and they remember their love for each other.
This was weird to me. Why have that be the center of your episode? And just throwing this out there, maybe they would be better off not together. They fight nonstop (as Lizzie says) which isn’t healthy and a bad example to their children. I’m not for divorce, but if you read the book, they got married for the wrong reasons and were very unhappy with each other. And if they fight constantly, it might be better to at least try counseling or a separation.
Later Darcy storms in and yells and is a jerk to Emma as he works with her. Ugh, can we cut him out.
Yes, a retelling made me say that. As I said I think the world is going to end.
So yeah, I do not have high hopes for this show, but I’ll keep on watching. The things I do for Jane.
Sometimes when I read/watch a really bad retelling, I’m kind of glad that Jane Austen isn’t alive to see it. I think she’d be mortified at some things we come up with.
For more Jane Austen film retellings, go to Mrs. Darcy Wants to Know the Truth!: Death Comes to Pemberley, Episode Three (2013)
For more Sense & Sensibility, go to Jane Austen Chinese Zodiac
For more Pride & Prejudice, go to Pride, Prejudice, and Personal Statements
For more Emma, go to Dull Times Breed Disaster
I’m sorry that you didn’t like it. Been there. As I think there are just not enough of Austen books I read retelling, but I haven’t found even one that I liked (I meen only books here, I enjoyed some tv series/movies). Some of them made me even upset like: Mr. Knightley as an easily irritated man without character, caring only for his mom (and being scared of her), or one of the characters (I don’t remember if it was Darcy or Mr. Knightly) being gay (but still with the partner Jane chose). Sometimes I think that people who do retelling just hate Jane.
I agree with you. I think some either hate her or its a quick cash story-you know people will read/watch. Hopefully this gets better, but we will see. 🙂